Showing posts with label Generation capacity. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Generation capacity. Show all posts

Wednesday, 10 June 2020

PSO Levy Reaches Highest Ever Amount to Fund Renewables

Electricity Bills Set to Rise (Once Again)





There is more headache on the way for Irish billpayers as the PSO Levy is set to reach it's highest ever amount at € 480 million, with the vast majority of it going to wind energy. This hike to electricity bills comes at a time when wholesale prices for electricity will be at their lowest since 2017 - when it was also €46 per MWh. So these savings will not be passed on to the consumer.

In fact, Irish consumers are locked into high energy costs for a long time. You may have voted for the Lisbon Treaty, which guaranteed an internal market with a highly competitive social market economy but you won't be getting that. 

The graph below shows how much electricity generating capacity has grown since 2006, at the height of the building boom. We had sufficient capacity then, but now we have twice as much as we need, with demand on or about the same. As wind farms cannot replace a conventional power station, it means that each new wind farm built is additional to our capacity requirements, and all of this excess capacity must be funded by consumers through taxes and levies and hidden costs.  


Electricity Generating Capacity for the Rep of Ireland
Dispatchable Plant is plant that can be switched on when required, e.g. gas, coal as opposed to 
wind energy which is intermittent and dependent on weather conditions



Sunday, 4 February 2018

Power Stations to Close

New Single Electricity Market rules now in force will see capacity payments cut by 30%.  In some cases, the power stations may not receive any capacity payment at all.

The inevitable consequence of this is the closure of older power stations and less dispatchable plant available to keep the lights on. Dispatchable plant is plant that can be switched on quickly when required. Renewables like Wind energy are not dispatchable because their output is uncontrollable. Ireland (All Island) currently has about 10,000MW of dispatchable plant and about 4,000MW of wind energy. About 1,000MW of capacity will not qualify for capacity payments. This leaves around 9,000MW of dispatchable plant remaining.



Dispatchable plant MW
Remaining dispatchable9,046
Max demand (2010)6,878
Capacity margin2,168
Minimum new data centres1,136
Capacity margin after data centres1,032
Reserve Generation500
Capacity Margin Net Surplus532



When everything is accounted for, including periods of high demand such as occurred in winter 2010 and planned data centres, there is a capacity margin of 1,032MW. Reserve generation is required incase a power station trips out. Currently this is about 500MW. This leaves a net capacity margin of 532MW.

This is quite tight but what happens if Viridian shut down not one but both of their gas power stations in Dublin (they have notified the Regulator that they will close both).  

This would leave a capacity margin of just 132MW. It would be lunacy to allow this to happen as blackouts would be inevitable in a harsh winter.  Dublin would be at most risk where there is a requirement for two large power stations to be on load at all times (three if the UK interconnector is out). 

While it would reduce costs, a blackout would come at a greater cost. 

And what of Northern Ireland ?  Where is the surplus power to come from to export to the North through the North South Interconnector ? The new auction will result in the closure of power stations in the North (Kilroot and part of Ballylumford). Northern Ireland is already at risk of power shortages.

But don't worry the Energy Regulator knows what they are doing I hear you thinking ? Well, I will just leave this here :

http://www.rte.ie/radio1/today-with-sean-o-rourke/podcasts/ 

Look for Tuesday 30th January "Electricity Supply".

The interviewer asks the Regulator how much power do the Viridian power stations supply in percentage terms ? It's worrying that the Regulator had not checked this very important statistic. She replies that they are 800MW capacity so out of 9,000MW, it would be a bit less than 10%. But the 9,000MW is not demand, it's total capacity (capacity must be higher than demand). She also never mentioned the little problem of a minimum requirement for power stations in Dublin. Again, something I thought she should know. 



1) SEMO Auction Results - http://www.sem-o.com/ISEM/General/Capacity%20Market%20-%20Final%20Capacity%20Auction%20Results%20Report.pdf

2) Eirgrid Constraints in Dublin Region -  http://www.eirgridgroup.com/site-files/library/EirGrid/Operational-Constraints-Update-January-2018.pdf

3) Planned Data Centres - http://www.iwea.com/industryreports

4) Maximum demand all time - http://smartgriddashboard.eirgrid.com/#all/demand

Sunday, 27 September 2015

Significant amounts of Generation in the pipeline

Eirgrid have announced that they are upgrading their transmission network to facilitate future increases in power generation.  Total planned generation will be 15,000MW by 2023 - three times that of peak winter demand. In otherwords, this is generation that is simply not required.


There is no mention of the cost or environmental impact of all this infrastructure. There is mention that in a period of volatile energy costs renewable energy sources can also contribute to cost competitiveness by reducing dependence on imported fossil fuels but as Irish Energy Blog has shown fossil fuel prices can come down in real life with investment in subsidized renewables preventing these savings from been passed on to the consumer :


Gas Prices Hit Six Year Low but still Electricity Bills rise


There is also the question of whether An Bord Pleanala (or the local planning authority) should carry out a cumulative assessment of this entire project, which includes new transmission and new generation, as it certainly looks like there will be significant environmental impacts.

Thursday, 23 July 2015

How many homes can a wind farm power ?


SSE Airtricity says that when built the wind farm will deliver enough green energy to power 84,000 homes, which is equivalent to almost 90% of the homes in County Galway.

A new wind farm to be built in Galway will be the largest in Ireland at 169MW. One might wonder where the figures for the number of homes to be powered by a wind farm or indeed any generating plant comes from. And is there a more accurate method of calculating this figure for a new wind farm  ?- as we shall see, the correct answer depends on the amount of wind farms already installed in the system.

The calculation used in the above newspaper article is as follows :

( 169MW capacity x 8,760 hours in a year x 28.5% capacity factor ) / 5MW annual power requirements for an average house

So it is envisaged that the output of the windfarm will on average be 28.5% of it's ideal output i.e. if the wind was blowing at the right speed for 100% of the time.

So there will be times that the output will be above 28.5% and times it will be below. Hence, the key word is on average. Average power is not as useful as reliable or dispatchable power. That is why a system powered completely by wind energy is impossible.   So the 84,000 homes will not be powered directly by the wind farm, but rather as part of a system that includes power from more reliable sources such as gas, peat, coal etc. It is only equivalent power that the wind farm generates. On their own, a wind farm cannot power a house at all.

So the statement above is accurate to a certain extent - enough and equivalent are the key words. But it is actual power that we need to consider. We need to convert this to the equivalent in reliable power. (We are back to the old argument about the difference between energy and power.)

Capacity credit is therefore a more useful method of calculating the number of houses that can be powered by a wind farm :

The inherently variable nature of wind power makes it necessary to analyse its adequacy impact differently from that of other generation units. The contribution of wind generation to generation adequacy is referred to as the capacity credit of wind. This capacity credit has been determined by subtracting a forecast of wind's half hourly generated output from the customer electricity demand curve. The use of this lower demand curve results in an improved adequacy position. The amount of conventional plant which leaves the system with the same improvement in adequacy as the net load curve is taken to be the capacity credit of wind [Eirgrid 2009].



Analysis of wind data has established that this capacity credit is roughly equivalent to itscapacity factor at low levels of wind penetration. However, the benefit tends towards saturation as wind penetration levels increase. This is because there is a significant risk of there being very low or very high wind speeds simultaneously across the country. This will result in all wind farms producing practically no output for a number of hours (note that turbines switch off during very high winds for safety reasons). In contrast, the forced outage probabilities for all thermal and hydro units are assumed to be independent of each other. Therefore, the probability of these units failing simultaneously is negligible [Eirgrid 2009].

So we can see that this gives us a more accurate measure of the contribution of wind towards powering homes. We are currently at about 2,300 MW of wind so adding the new Galway wind farm will bring us to about 2,500MW. The capacity credit for new wind farms reduces as we install more wind farms so wind farms installed back in 2008 and 2009 contributed more to the overall system than ones installed today in 2015. This is because, to put it quite simply, the risk of blackouts increases (as does wind curtailment). Conventional gas generators will be placed on high alert for the next few years as we install more and more wind.

So our new 169MW wind farm will contribute only about 30-40MW to the overall electricity system in conventional generator terms. This equates to about 17,000 homes or 20% of the number of homes stated above.

Are we really getting bang for our buck, considering the environmental impact (about 70,000 tonnes of concrete will be required in its installation) and cost to the consumer of this wind farm   ?

Saturday, 11 October 2014

Is there an energy bubble in Ireland ?




Key To Graph:

Dispatchable Plant : Fossil fuel and hydro plant.
Average Demand : Average electricity consumption over the year.
Actual Peak Demand: Peak demand each year
Forced outages: the rate at which plant unexpectedly break down
Total : Total of all generation capacity - wind, hydro, fossil fuel, East West interconnector.


The above chart shows the increase in electricity generation capacity in Ireland (from Eirgrid Generation Adequacy Reports). The dotted line shows Eirgrid’s demand estimate back in 2008 when Eamon Ryan was minister (Eirgrid Grid25 Report 2008). 2009 was the year when Ireland began adding more plant, mostly gas, and the gap between generation capacity and falling electricity demand began to widen. As a result, forced outages, the rate at which plant unexpectedly break down, decreased due to this upgrading of old fleet. Dispatchable plant, made up of fossil fuel, pumped storage and hydro, rose by about 800 MW and total generating capacity, including wind, rose by just over 2000 MW since 2006.


This then sums up quite nicely the two main problems arising out of Ireland’s current energy policy:


1) The inability of wind energy to displace conventional fossil fuel plant - as wind energy is an intermittent and unreliable source of energy, it is incapable of displacing plant powered from other conventional sources. This is undoubtedly the case in Ireland and everywhere else.

Eirgrid publish a report every year, stating how reliable their electricity supply is - they call this generation adequacy. If they had a mix of gas and coal plants, with a few extra spare plant for back up, they would be able to report a good generation adequacy. Adding a small bit of wind wouldn’t affect this. The paradox with wind is that the more wind energy you add to the mix, the more unreliable the electricity supply becomes and the more generation adequacy becomes eroded. Eirgrid refer to this as the capacity credit for wind. A generator with a high capacity credit means you can safely shut down other plant and replace it with that generator. Wind energy’s capacity credit is much lower than other energy sources and it diminishes with the more you wind you add.
So to sum up, wind energy, no matter how much of it you have, can never replace a fossil fuel plant.


2) The additional costs arising out of the above - The facts are that all plant in the system, whether it is fossil fuel or wind, have to paid for by the consumer. As can be seen in the graph, average demand and average peak demand have fallen. This means that given Ireland’s large amounts of plant, some of this plant is lying idle. But this plant can’t be allowed to close down, as it may be needed for reserve or to meet a spike in peak demand. Indeed, data from SEMO shows that Tynagh gas plant in Galway only provided electricity to the grid for roughly the equivalent of two months last year but received € 65 million from the market. On top of this, through the PSO levy it received € 69 for security of supply. Tynagh claim that it now runs less due to increased wind penetration.  Without these payments, the plant would have to close down, but Eirgrid cannot take the risk of losing this capacity (as it is dispatchable as opposed to been intermittent). There are other plants around the country in the same position such as Tarbert and Great Island heavy fuel oil plants that keep 5 days worth of heavy fuel oil on site at all times. Tarbert was actually due to close in 2013 but this has been delayed till after 2020. Rhode power plant in Offaly is another example. They said in a recent EPA report that lower demand from the Grid has resulted in the plant running for just 17 hours in 2013. Tawnaghmore plant in Mayo ran for even less at 10 hours. If you are in charge of operating the grid, then you either decide to allow these plants to close or you increase electricity bills to cover the fixed costs of these plants. As you can’t rely on 2000MW of wind, then you only have one choice available to you - keep them open.


As for the wind farms, they need to be paid too. I have obtained the payments from SEMO for the roughly 2,000MW of wind installed at the end of 2013. The total came to € 277 million. On top of this, there are curtailment and constraint payments in the region of € 140 million. So electricity bills were increased by about € 400 million to pay for wind farms. The PSO levy is an additional cost due to wind. This recovers costs for the energy supplier who have to accept variable wind energy from generators. Last year this was € 51 million (In 2014, it has been set at € 94 million). So the total cost to the consumer for wind energy last year was roughly € 450 million (not including the other hidden costs too such as transmission etc).


So it should be clear from the above, that each additional MW of wind, costs extra to the consumer - it doesn’t replace the cost of a MW coming from somewhere else. Some might argue that as wind energy reduces fossil fuel consumption, that there is a cost saving. But I would argue that fossil fuel savings are largely irrelevant to the end user cost of electricity. The relatively idle plants above are paid, not on the basis of fuel consumed, but on the basis of making their capacity available. This is inherent in the market payments structure where plant receive capacity payments as well as energy payments. For these reasons, wholesale costs reductions can never translate into retail cost reductions. The situation is made worse with the fact that demand has fallen since all this additional capacity has been added.


I could have put another line in the graph for electricity prices going up, up and up each year. Wind capacity is due to be doubled in the next few years. This will bring total generation capacity to over 10,000MW. All of this 10,000MW plus of thermal plant and wind will have to be paid for by businesses and households that only consume about a third of that capacity in electricity, and at most in the depths of winter, less than half. Electricity prices in the coming years may make water charges look like small change.


What’s the situation with biomass ?


There is a case been put forward for converting Moneypoint to biomass as an argument for doing away with the need for wind farms and pylons. The main point here is that biomass provides dispatchable generation just like coal does. So a biomass conversion would neatly displace the old coal plant, replacing its costs to the consumer aswell (i.e. regardless of the cost of the conversion and running of the new plant, the old coal plant and its costs would be gone, whereas with wind, it can’t replace a coal or gas plant).


In any case, the right thing now is to put a moratorium on all new plant, whether wind or otherwise, unless it is replacing old fleet.

So to go back to the original title of this post - is there an energy bubble ? Well, the signs are clear that there is one. A huge surplus of capacity over and above what the market needs as explained above is one sign. There are also other signs like the over-valuing of assets, as was seen in the sell off of Bord Gais's Whitegate plant. And then there is government interference in the market, e.g, the State aid given to wind power in the form of REFIT, fixing the price of wind energy over and above its real market value.

This is all reminiscent of the recent housing bubble, but will the government pay heed to the increasing number of critics of their policy this time ?