Showing posts with label Renewable targets 2020. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Renewable targets 2020. Show all posts

Sunday, 23 January 2022

Ireland Ranks near bottom of Renewable Targets Table

 Wind Energy Oriented Renewable Plans Fared Badly


Ireland just about reached it's 2020 renewable target of 16% equalling Poland, a country not exactly renowned for its love of the "green religion". Ireland ranked 20th out of the 27th member states. Only Belgium, Luxembourg, Malta, Holland and Hungary ranked lower.

So the question must be asked - where did Ireland go wrong after spending billions on renewable energy and building 5,000MW of wind farms ? 

Surely if wind speeds are so high in Ireland as we are often told, then Ireland should be in the top 10 of Europe ? 

Sweden, Croatia, Finland, Bulgaria, Latvia and Austria topped the list of renewable energy performers in the EU.

Here are the main sources of renewable energy for each country :

Sweden - hydro, biomass. Exports a lot of electricity to Finland.

Croatia - hydro with some wind and solar. Imports a lot of electricity.

Bulgaria - hydro and solar. 

Finland - biomass and hydro. Imports a lot of electricity from Sweden and Russia.

Latvia - biomass and hydro.

Austria - biomass and hydro.

And for countries outside the EU - - 

Iceland - geothermal.

Norway - hydro. Norway has 65 times as much hydro as wind.

This clearly shows that the most successful renewables are Hydro and bioenergy/biomass. There are also significant benefits to interconnection especially if the neighbouring country has a lot of hydro. For instance, Denmark has a similar amount of wind energy to Ireland, but relies heavily on imports from hydro based electricity in Norway and Sweden which means wind has to do a lot less heavy lifting than in Ireland (because imported electricity is emission free). Denmark ranks in the top 10 of the EU renewable energy targets table for this reason.

It looks like Ireland backed the wrong horse with wind energy.  However, based on past performance, it is unlikely that Ireland will put the brakes on and assess the situation.







Sunday, 3 January 2021

The Null Hypothesis by Pat Swords

“Making predictions is difficult, particularly about the future”, but we can learn an awful lot from the past, but regretfully generally choose not to do so. The EU attaches considerable importance to its renewable programme, and indeed, in early 2020 the ‘European Green Deal’ of striving to be the first climate-neutral continent, is the most important objective of the new EU presidency. Before analysing the EU’s methods for assigning its priorities, it is worthwhile reflecting on how some other ‘walks of life’ follow due process in their designations of value and substance.

In comparison to the EU, which has only existed for a few decades, the Catholic Church spans two millennia through times of considerable upheaval. So how does the Catholic Church decide on its most important honours, i.e. that of sainthood? In reality the position of advocatus diaboli, or devil's advocate, has existed at the Vatican for centuries, and as explained by the ‘The Catholic Encyclopedia’:


• The duty of the Promotor Fidei was to oversee every aspect of the beatification and canonization process, ensuring that no person received the honors of sainthood rashly, that proper juridical form was observed, and that every potential weakness or objection to the saints canonization was raised and evaluated in order that only those who were truly worthy would be raised to the dignity of the altars. Because the Promotor Fidei took a juridical position against the canonization of any given saint, it was joked that he was taking the devil's part in the proceedings, hence the common appellation "Devils' Advocate" (advocatus diaboli).


Science has also existed for a long period, and while the application of new scientific knowledge in the last century has transformed the quality of life enjoyed by humankind, science has had a few failures on the way, such as eugenics. So how does science decide that a hypothesis is of value, where a hypothesis is a proposed explanation for a phenomenon? 

The widely accepted, traditional ‘scientific method’ is based on formulating and testing hypotheses, in which from the results of subsequent experimentations, a deduction is made as to whether the hypothesis is presumably true or false. In its essence, it is a form of critical thinking and deductive reasoning, but at its core is the principle that the hypothesis and the resulting testing of the hypothesis must be inherently falsifiable. In simple terms, to be acceptable as a scientific theory, there must be a possible negative answer.

The null hypothesis is therefore the hypothesis, which the researcher tries to disprove, reject or nullify. For example, if people take Aspirin and their headache regularly goes away, then a valid hypothesis is that Aspirin is an effective pain medication. However, the null hypothesis would point out that headaches have always come and gone. This is why in pharmaceutical research blind placebo trials are used. If the group taking the Aspirin demonstrate an improved response with respects to headaches, then it is appropriate to adopt Aspirin, as an accepted proven medication for these purposes.

As far back as 1660, with the founding of the Royal Society in England, which is the oldest national scientific institution, they adopted as their motto: Nullius in verba (Latin for "on the word of no one" or "take nobody's word for it"). Equally, the portrayal of Einstein is often that of an older wise man, but he was young and essentially unknown in 1905, when he published his theory of relativity. A theory challenging the Newtonian physics established for more than 200 years. Some considered him an upstart and a scientific book was even published "Hundert Autoren Gegen Einstein (One Hundred Authors against Einstein)". Einstein alleged reply was that to refute relativity one would not need the word of a hundred scientists, just one fact, which no one had produced.

Consensus may therefore be at the core of politics, but it is not science. Richard Feynman was another famous physicist, who worked on the Manhattan Project to develop the atomic bomb and was a Nobel Prize winner. As he stated with respect to scientific consensus: “It does not matter who you are, or how smart you are, or what title you have, or how many of you there are, and certainly not how many papers your side has published, if your prediction is wrong then your hypothesis is wrong. Period.” Science therefore moves forward in incremental steps by attrition, at its heart is an inherently sceptical approach, while the Catholic Church by formalising the role of the advocatus diabolic also demonstrates, as to how it values such scepticism.

It is of course appropriate that the scientific literature represents various hypotheses, but a more recent development is how the drive for researchers to obtain publication in the more prominent journals, has led to more exaggerated attention grabbing claims to be made. Even the mainstream media has noticed that there is now a reproducibility crisis in science, such that when researchers try to reproduce published experimental work, they frequently get significantly different results. Yet replication of experimental research is at the heart of the scientific process.

The previous reference to scientific academics publishing papers on their favourite hypothesis, peer reviewed by like-minded academics, might initially appear somewhat harsh, but it does not seem to bother them much when they get it wrong. For example, the ‘ex-post’ analysis of the original assessment for the 20% renewable energy programme does not make pretty reading. Despite this, the PRIMES model and its academic developers are a key component of the economic analysis of the next phase of the EU’s climate strategies and targets.

The difference with engineering is that as previously highlighted, it is the practical application of science. For example, the fundamentals of bridge design are not scientific hypotheses, but the output of previously validated research and testing. The consequences of getting it wrong are simply too high, which is why there is such criticism coming from experienced engineers, with respect to the manner in which this whole renewable energy programme has been progressed.

How to Assign a Value to this Renewable Programme


This leads to the final claim in Section 5 ‘Conclusion’ of the 2006 Renewable Energy Road Map namely: “The value of this significant reduction in greenhouse gas emissions would nearly cover the total additional cost under high energy prices”.

As Section 4.1 demonstrates, the Road Map is concluding with a completely circular form of reasoning to justify the value of the greenhouse gas savings made. In that the carbon price per tonne is effectively, a tax placed on fossil fuels. While the use of renewables is exempt from this tax, so increasing the use of renewables leads to a tax saving, which in turn helps cover the additional costs spent on renewables. This may well be adequate political reasoning for some, but there are a number of equally valid questions others require answering:

• Firstly, the “additional cost associated with reaching the proposed share of renewable energy” were grossly underestimated, such that a complete bonanza occurred for those supplying wind turbines, solar panels and wood chips, which the ‘hard pressed’ citizen had to fund in addition to the €25 per tonne carbon tax added to the use of fossil fuels. Why did this happen, when under Article 3(3) of the Lisbon Treaty (TEU) the Union shall work for “a highly competitive social market economy?” 

• Why is the ‘hard pressed’ citizen having to pay this carbon tax and if its justification is the ‘polluter pays principle’, on what basis was €25 per tonne evaluated? 

• When scientific logic and reasoning is applied, what valuation is appropriate to these greenhouse gas savings?

 As regards the first question above, citizens should seek an explanation of this nature from those allegedly elected to represent you. As regards the second question, carbon prices are in 2020 currently trading at circa €25 per tonne, where the allocation of free ‘allowances’ largely determines the price on the EU ETS. As explained in Section 4.1, the allocations of free allowances is solely a political decision, hence the EU ETS is a tax applied to fossil fuels and as to why it is applied, where it is applied and as to how much is applied is solely a political decision. There is no connection to the environmental damage cost, i.e. external cost, of CO2. So again, citizens should seek an explanation from those allegedly elected to represent you.

What is also glaringly obvious with the ‘Renewable Energy Road Map’ and the subsequent renewable programme, is that the carbon reductions were sole decision criterion. There was no connection to any other externalities; such as if you force one type of energy delivery system off the market to promote another, other significant externalities may arise. For example, as reported in the European Environment Agency’s Air quality in Europe - 2016 report. “The use of wood and other biomass combustion for household heating is growing in some countries, owing to government incentives/subsidies, rising costs of other energy sources, and an increased public perception that it is a 'green' option”. This Report has a specific section on “Residential biomass combustion: an important source of air pollution”, as levels of fine particulates, which have the highest health impact of the common air pollutants, are increasing due to this biomass use. 

Regretfully, this renewable programme is having a serious impact on the prior successes achieved under the CAFÉ programme, as particulate levels in urban areas, where these fine particulates are the most damaging of the common air pollutants in terms of health, are rising again. Equally, the German wild animal foundation points out with respect to the unacceptable impacts of any further installations of wind turbines in forested areas, some 250,000 bats and 12,000 raptors (birds of prey) being killed by wind turbines each year in Germany. After several years of intensive conservation measures in the 1980s and 1990s, the number of successful raptor breeding pairs, which was increasing, is now once again in decline. While, Section 4.4 has already highlight the serious concerns associated with low frequency noise from wind turbines and the WHO’s position on this externality.

To derive a value based on externalities, one has to weight up both the positive and negative externalities and do so in a competent and transparent manner. However, to complete the former, one should logically first assign an estimate to the actual carbon savings being realised? Section 6.3 shows how the majority of the predicted emission savings were to occur in electricity generation. While as previously evaluated, there are significant questions in relation to the validity of emission savings reported for this sector, not least due to the negative impact of intermittent renewable sources on conventional generation and the actual life cycle of emissions associated with bioenergy. However, let us assign an annual emission saving attributed to the implementation of the whole programme of 300 Mt, on the basis that the data does not really support a value either double that or half that.

Section 3 already articulated as to how ExternE in 2000 finally recommended the use of a ‘central estimate’ of the external cost of CO2 of €2.4 per tonne, with a ‘minimum’ value of €0.1 per tonne and a ‘maximum’ value of €16.4 per tonne. Simple sums to convert these to a price basis in 2020 and multiplying by 300 Mt, results in the annual valuation of external costs avoided as documented below: 



Essentially the external cost avoided ranges from €0.04 billion to €6.9 billion, with €1 billion as the central estimate. Yet as documented renewable electricity in Germany alone is resulting in surcharges of €26.5 billion per annum, plus additional costs related to inefficient operation of power station and for the funding of allowances on the EU ETS. Equally, the data shows that renewable investments in the EU, which typically have a lifespan of 20 years, are already in the scale of a trillion Euros, which over that timeframe is an average of €50 billion per annum, to which it is necessary to add operational costs, taxes and profit. 

No matter how one looks at it, the ratio of financial costs to benefits is pretty awful, which also indicates, that for this programme to make sense from a cost benefit perspective, the ExternE assessment of the external cost of CO2 would need to be an underestimate by several multiples. However in this regard, as documented already in Section 3 in relation to the work of Professor Richard Tol, a Dutch economist, who in a later 2009 publication on the “Economic Effects of Climate Change” stated: 

    • “Projections of future emissions and future climate change have become less severe over time - even though the public discourse has become shriller”. Ultimately, we all have to sit down to a banquet of consequences; the statement above is accurate, while assumptions as to the value of these CO2 savings are just assumptions. Another metric for expressing the value of 300 Mt of CO2 savings is a comparison with annual global emissions as shown in Figure 8.1 overleaf. These have now reached and slightly exceeded 35 billion tonnes of CO2 equivalent per annum. Therefore, annual savings from the EU’s renewable energy programme amount to 0.9% of the global total.



- Extract from Pat's book :

Monday, 17 June 2019

Spending Overruns Undermine Emissions Targets


The European Court of Auditors expect that many EU countries, including Ireland, will not meet their 2020 targets for the share of total energy from renewables :


  • six Member States are unlikely to meet their 2020 target as they need an increase in the share from renewables by: the Netherlands 7.4 pp, France 6.7 pp, Ireland 5.3 pp, the United Kingdom 4.8 pp, Luxembourg 4.6 pp and Poland 4.1 pp.  

  •   the Netherlands shows the largest gap, with an actual average share of 5.9% for 2015/2016, versus an indicative RED trajectory of 7.6%. The gap to the planned NREAP share of 9.7% renewable energy in 2016 is even larger. 

    •  for 11 Member States (Belgium, Cyprus France, Greece, Ireland, Luxembourg, Malta, the Netherlands, Poland, Portugal and the United Kingdom), currently implemented renewable energy policies and already planned renewable energy policy initiatives appear today to be insufficient to trigger the required renewable energy volumes purely domestically. 

    • In addition, for 7 Member States (Austria, Germany, Latvia, Romania, Slovenia, Slovakia and Spain) there is some uncertainty related to 2020 renewable energy target achievement. Their capability of meeting their 2020 national binding targets will to a great extend depend on the levels of energy demand in case there would be a large increase in energy demand that brings their energy consumption back in line with the original trend indicated by the latest EU reference scenario.   

This should be seen as a serious indictment of Ireland's wind only policy which has completely failed to reduce emissions at any meaningful level. The idea that the EU will fine every one of these countries, that are also unlikely to meet their targets, now seems increasingly unlikely, as the widespread impracticality of the targets becomes manifest.

Ireland has already spent €86 million in buying carbon credits to offset it's high emissions with the cost potentially running to billions over the next decade. As with health and foreign aid policy (in fact every policy), Ireland's answer is always to spend more (taxpayers) money instead of doing some actual analysis to uncover the root cause of the problem.


Sustainable Economics is a Sustainable Environment


The simple fact, as this blog has pointed out previously, is that the more the government spend, the higher the emissions. Higher welfare spending, for example, results in more resources consumed beyond our means, more imported goods, higher immigration and more waste material like plastics. High government and private debt also encourages more wasteful spending.

A policy that would encourage more savings and less debt would result in lower emissions. Higher savings means more deferred purchasing, which means lower emissions in the short to medium term. 

It is perhaps somewhat ironic that the most climate change obsessed government in Irish history is also the worst offender when it comes to out of control spending. The Irish Fiscal Council last week reported that the government breached post financial crisis spending rules last year, and the increases in spending in recent years were not "conducive to prudent economic and budgetary management".   They warned that the spending had reached a similar magnitude to those prior to the 2008 crisis (funnily enough when the green party were last in government). Cormac Lucey has worked out that the cost of the spending overruns last year was € 3,500 per person living in the state. Instead of putting away the additional tax receipts into a rainy day fund, which would have lowered emissions, every cent has been squandered. 

And the more the government continues to spend recklessly, the more carbon credits they will need to purchase to offset the extra emissions meaning that the spending overruns are set to become a vicious cycle. If Ireland wants to get serious about reducing emissions it  needs a prudent government.


Saturday, 23 March 2019

Wind Industry Admits Wind Energy Costs Money

But claim only as little as €1 per person


A recent Irish Wind Energy Association report has stated that the total net cost of wind energy to the consumer has been one euro per person per year since 2000. It is an interesting report for a number of reasons, not least, that this is the first time the wind industry in Ireland have admitted that wind energy costs money. 

The total cost calculated was €0.1bn, but this includes savings from not having to pay EU fines of € 0.7bn. Since it now looks like we will miss our targets regardless of how much more Ireland invests in wind (and unlikely in any event that the EU will impose fines on Member States), the actual cost then of wind energy according to the report was €0.8bn , eight times the cost claimed.  

Their calculations were based on wholesale price and capacity payments savings of €2.5bn  on one side and costs of €3.3bn on the other side arising from the PSO Levy, DS3, grid investment and constraint costs. This is the first time that the wind industry have acknowledged that these last three costs are directly related to increased levels of wind. This blog has argued that they should be included as wind related costs for many years now. 

I have shown before that the link between higher levels of wind and lower wholesale prices is tenuous. Wholesale prices are actually rising as investment in wind is at it's peak. The wind industry report used models to calculate their wholesale price savings rather than real data. I can no longer find any real time pricing data on the new SEMO website.  But if it is really the case that wind has led to €2.3bn in wholesale price savings plus €200m in capacity payments savings, then that means that power stations have taken a hit of €2.5bn over the 20 year period, with some additional revenue of €0.5bn from additional constraint payments. So about €2bn in lost revenue, the equivalent of about one whole year of wholesale payments lost to fossil fuel generators.  There is some evidence that has come out in recent days that shows that power stations are now losing money. Last year, ESB were forced to write down the value of two of their power stations. 

Finally, the report admits what I've been writing about for years, that only 10-11% of wind energy can be relied on as equivalent conventional capacity (capacity credit) :


The rate at which wind capacity reduces the capacity requirement is defined by the wind capacity credit, which is around 11% of installed wind capacity.

Under the I-SEM capacity market rules, wind receives a capacity credit of about 10% and OCGTs a capacity credit of about 92%. This means that 1 GW of wind is replaced by 109 MW (= 1 GW * (10% / 92%) of OCGTs.

The Wind Aware Ireland report goes into detail on the various wind related costs (they calculated a cost of € 1.2bn per year). I do not want to rehash all of those points, for those interested you can read the report here. But for further proof that costs across the board are increasing every year as more wind is added, one need look no further than the recent Ancillary Systems Services Report released by Eirgrid. When compared with the same report from three years ago, the costs to maintain back up reserves has more than doubled :






The full IWEA report can be read here.

Saturday, 2 March 2019

Alternative Renewables - Waste to Energy








Dates : 12th and 13th January, 2019 [Source SEM-O] 
As the renewable energy programme has proceeded in Ireland without any form of supporting analysis, there has never been a proper economic assessment of the cost of reducing carbon emissions, using wind energy or any of the other ten sources of renewable energy listed in Directive 2009/28/EC.


Indeed, of the eleven different sources of renewable energy defined in the 2009 Directive, many are of a diffuse nature and more suited to being applied for heat energy rather than the generation of electricity. An example of this being the use of solar energy for water heating, which is a simple technology approach, such as circulating water through evacuated glass tubes.

Typical well-installed systems provide up to 60% of hot water demand over 12 months [SEAI].

The cost effectiveness of this approach can be determined from the fact that such installations were in use even before grants for their installation became available, as could also be said in relation to biomass (wood based) heating systems and aerothermal and geothermal systems for space heating.

If we consider a Waste to Energy (WtE) plant, the waste is combusted at a minimum temperature of 850 ⁰C producing in the boiler high pressure steam for electricity generation and hot water for use in district heating. Some 50% of the waste is of biogenic origin (biomass) and therefore 50% of energy produced is from a renewable source.

If this waste had instead gone to landfill, the biogenic fraction would have rotted and produced methane, which is a global warming gas with a Global Warming Potential (GWP) of 28 – 36 over 100 years. In other words it is some 28 to 36 times more potent than carbon dioxide. While the landfill gas collection system would have captured some of this methane for combustion in gas engines, figures show that of the order of 40% is directly released to atmosphere. In a WtE plant, the heat and mass balance shows 810 kWh of electricity produced per tonne of Municipal Solid Waste (MSW) combusted with about 0.72 kg biogenic CO2 and 0.53 kg fossil CO2 per kWh of direct emissions.

In the same timeframe that a 2004 report by ESB was stating that utilising a low penetration of wind energy to reduce a tonne of carbon dioxide was €120, it was being reported that the cost to avoid 1 tonne of CO2 with WtE was about €43, whereas the costs to avoid 1 tonne of CO2 with (other) biomass was €80. Indeed, if district heating systems are used in addition to solely electrical outputs, then this WtE CO2 avoidance cost reduces to the range €7 to €20.

It is therefore very difficult to reconcile these values with the claims made by many greens in Ireland, which are provided without any supporting evidence, that wind energy represents Ireland’s “cheapest renewable electricity resource”. But there is also evidence that increasing amounts of wind energy is discriminating against other forms of renewable energy.

The figure at the top of this article shows the relevant capacity factors for wind energy in Ireland and a Waste to Energy plant in Co. Meath over two days in January 2019. This facility treats some 200,000 tonnes of MSW per annum, with an electricity output of 18 MW, which was until recently a continuous output, with over 50% being classified as renewable. Outside of a short annual maintenance period this output is continuous so the WtE developer could in this case justifiably claim that this 18 MW is “enough to power more than 22,000 homes”


Yet there was so much wind energy on the grid on the 12th and 13th January that other generators had to be taken off line and kept on hot standby ready to ramp up, when the inevitable happened and the wind dropped. This can be clearly seen in the graph, where the WtE plant had to be taken off the grid for extended periods. However, such a waste to energy plant can’t be simply throttled back, the waste is still arriving and the furnace temperature has to be kept at a minimum of 850 ⁰C. Instead the steam generated simply has to be dumped into the plant’s cooling system rather than be used to generate steam. Not only is this a loss of revenue to the WtE operator, but it is reflected in resulting higher costs for waste disposal of those using that facility.


It could be argued that discrimination is occurring, in that renewable energy produced at the WtE plant, in a far more reliable and cost effective manner, now has to be dumped to facilitate ever more wind energy being placed on the grid. Wind energy, which by its highly variable and intermittent nature is deeply flawed for the production of significant amounts of electricity. Indeed, as is shown above, this wind output basically isn’t there when it is needed for days on end and then it floods the grid for a short period with high inputs. This can only be managed by discriminating against other users, including those which are lower cost and more reliable renewable inputs. It is also fair to say that this is what you get, when you allow a ‘wild west’ of wind farm developments, without any analysis, without any assessments or without any of the legally required rules to ensure that authorisation is transparent, proportionate and does not discriminate between individual renewable technologies.