Monday, 29 February 2016

Apple data centre delayed

There's an interesting twist in the Apple data centre saga as An Bord Pleanala have raised questions about it's renewable credentials :


"An Bord Pleanála’s second issue is how Apple will make good on its promise to power the centre entirely from renewable energy. The letter said: “No site or project-specific information regarding renewable energy projects is provided and details of how they might be connected to the proposed development is required.”

Obviously, most of Apple's claims about renewable energy are hocus pocus designed to appeal to young hipsters but now they will actually have to back up their claims with a plan based on engineering reality rather than ideology. Things could get tricky for them.

Thursday, 25 February 2016

France ignores European Court of Justice ruling

Ireland is likely to miss its renewable energy targets for 2020, resulting in hefty fines - Irish Times, 2015.
I came across this article today and it struck me as another good example of how judgements made by the European Court of Justice are simply ignored by Member States - in this case, France. Too often we peasants are threatened by our political class with fines from our European masters. But if France don't bother complying with ECJ rulings, then why should Ireland, or anyone else for that matter ? 






There are good reasons to believe that France, Germany, Greece, Poland, Spain and the UK will miss their 2020 targets. The bogeyman of EU fines should not be used to force the people of Ireland to accept short term, hasty and poorly thought out decisions on energy.


References

Likelihood of Member States meeting their 2020 targets :
See pages 78-79 of EPAW submission - http://westcorkwind.com/images/Adobe/EPAW_N-S.pdf


I'm French, but I've lost my patience with the EU. I'll be voting Leave - Article published by Telegraph, Feb 2015

Wednesday, 24 February 2016

Does Ireland have Low Cost Renewables ?


A recent report by the Council of European Energy Regulators (CEER) has been rolled out lately by the Department of Energy as evidence that their policy of more and more wind energy is a low cost one. According to the report, Ireland has a renewable support of € 2.03 compared to the EU average of € 13.68. Sounds pretty good, right ?

Well, once again, the data refers to the year 2012, just like the SEAI report that is also rolled out by wind energy proponents. Somewhere around 600-700MW of wind has been added since then. The report also looks at 2013 but curiously there is no data for Ireland for this year. 

So why is 2012 chosen and not any of the subsequent years ? Well, the wholesale price of electricity was high in this year. Why is this relevant ? The higher the wholesale price, the lower the renewable subsidy required and vice versa. The level of support was calculated by subtracting the REFIT (or subsidized) price from the wholesale price for 2012 :


In the case of FITs [Feed-in-Tariffs], the level of support was estimated by subtracting the average wholesale electricity price from the overall tariff and therefore is not the same as the full FIT granted to producers.


CEER used a wholesale price of € 63.20 for 2012 (click on graph to show wholesale price) :


But if we look at a recent day, the wholesale price is now between € 20 and € 40 : 




The Energy Regulator (CER) calculates the annual cost of renewable supports each year, taking into account the wholesale prices and the installed capacity of renewable generators. This is then used to calculate the PSO Levy to be applied to energy bills.  Back in 2012, the PSO Levy was still in it's infancy with a total cost relating to renewable energy (mainly wind) of  just € 37 million. 

But by 2016, the CER had calculated total renewable supports (again mainly wind) of € 181 million, almost five times the cost for 2012.  The CER cite lower wholesale prices, lower capacity payments and more renewables, mostly wind, as the drivers in the increase. 

Demand is now around 26,500 GWh so if we work out renewables support per unit of electricity consumed we now get € 6.83 for 2016, over three times the cost for 2012 that CEER have calculated.

Evidently, this is only the direct cost of renewables like wind. There are other, mostly hidden, system costs that are subsidized by consumers. The CEER report acknowledged this point in relation to the grid costs in Ireland :


In addition, in Ireland, the generator pays 100% of the construction of the Least Cost Connection physical connection to the transmission system i.e. the shallow connection works. Any deep reinforcements required to facilitate the connections are not charged to the generator. 


We can throw in another € 4 billion plus for that. 

When Ireland goes offshore, the experience in other EU countries tells us that it will require a higher subsidy that onshore wind, so the cost of renewables will rise further again. In 2012, many other EU countries had offshore wind whereas Ireland did not.

It is also interesting to note that certain EU countries like Poland, Belgium and Sweden never introduced tariffs or subsidies for renewables, instead opting for Green Certificates. Are we really comparing like with like here ?

Lastly, have a look at pages 57-67 of the CEER report. Spain, Portugal, Greece and Ireland all opted for exclusively feed in tariffs supports. Italy used a mix of supports including FITs. Then if we add the total cost we get Spain € 6 billion, Portugal € 700 million, Greece € 1.1 billion and Italy € 9.5 billion. The PIIGS countries spent over € 17 billion on renewables supports in 2012, at a time when their banks and economies were going down the drain. Most of these countries are still in financial distress. 

Were the likes of Sweden, Romania, Poland and Belgium craftier when they opted for Green Certificates rather than fixed subsidies like Ireland and Greece  ? I can't really say for sure, but I have a hunch that they were.


References :

CEER Status Review of Renewable and Energy Efficiency Support Schemes in Europe in 2012 and 2013 (January 2015)

PSO Levy Paper for year ending 30th September 2012 - see page 19, cost of REFIT and AER schemes.

PSO Levy Paper for year ending 30th September 2016 - see page 4.

Tuesday, 23 February 2016

The Future of Oil Exploration

Guest Post by David Whitehead, geologist and paleoclimatologist

 Irish offshore  oil and gas may well be on it's last legs. The success ratio is too low, the oil price is too low ( and will remain so for decades although with occasional spikes due to political and/or logistical crises). Corrib has shown how investor unfriendly we are, the geology of the Irish offshore is very difficult ( thick chalk over prospective horizons) and the sea conditions are deep water and  highly exposed to  weather  extremes ( there are regularly 50 ft high waves and hurricane force winds  off our South and West coasts) . That is why there is so little interest in exploration of the Irish offshore - whatever the hypothetical resource base might be. Eamon Ryan is delusional in as far as he seems to believe that if we raise taxes on production sufficiently  the oil companies  will be induced into coming here and  exploring the Irish offshore.

Moreover people do not appreciate that shale oil and gas and directional drilling and developments in  hydraulic  fracture propagation and maintenance ( frakking for short) has radically changed the paradigm of the oil and gas  from being a resource constrained business - where the source of rent is the rarity and difficulty of finding an economic reserve - to an industrial process which can be successfully applied over wide areas largely eliminating exploration risk. These developments have allowed the USA to change from being the world’s largest oil importer to being an oil and gas EXPORTER. This, and the revival of production in Iraq and Iran ( following the end of sanctions) have collapsed the price of oil on world markets.

The principal requirement for success and hence the economic rent will in future come from being able to obtain a production permit and satisfying  the production regulations   ( esp. environmental compliance) so as to be able to produce from very widespread   bituminous shale  resources using “frakking” techniques, rather than from having  to discover an oil or gas field from which hydrocarbons  flow spontaneously under natural pressure or induced by water injection  and CO2 flooding. The Anti frakkers worked this out - hence the nature of the anti frakking strategy.  They are not interested in the environment or people’s lives - they want to end the Capitalist system  and       realised that  the best way to do this is to deprive it of cheap energy.  

This sort of  transformation happens from time to time  in industry - think of the change in dynamics caused by the discovery of how to breed salmon in captivity - Salmon went from being the rarest and most expensive of fish to being  one of the cheapest and most widely available. Similarly the invention of the process to recover nitrates from air killed the Chilean and Peruvian nitrate mining business and allowed the expansion of fertilizer manufacture which permitted  the enormous growth  of  global agricultural production ( not to mention the explosives required for WWI and WWII).There are many other examples (especially how steam power eliminated wind and water milling and the sailing ship!)

The old oil and gas  business model relied on the source of economic rent being  the discovery of rare and difficult to find oil and gas fields and such discoveries, required specialised geophysical surveys, and interpretative expertise. This was  time consuming , expensive and subject to very high failure risk. Once a field was discovered, if it was big enough, it would be economic. The OPEC strategy of keeping oil prices high meant that it was sensible to explore in remote and difficult areas such as the north Slope of Alaska, the North Sea and the Gulf of Mexico. Many of these fields were developed and  those  in production will continue to produce because the marginal cost of production is  low ( often $<10/bbl ). Many  old fields will now be able to stay in production   much longer because the new methods allow recovery of oil not  previously accessible. The average recovery of oil from an existing field with earlier technology - including CO2 and water  flooding`-  is only around 1/3 rd of the contained amount.  Now in many cases  much of the remaining resource can  be recovered. This will extend the life of many  oilfields already in existence  around the world.


Oil and gas have ceased to be scarce resources - forget about peak oil theories - we have and can access enough oil and gas  to last at least a couple more centuries - by which time we might not need it as a fuel anymore as small scale ,fail-safe fission reactors  and perhaps even small scale fusion technology will most likely be available.

The Greens have lost the bet!

Sunday, 21 February 2016

General Election 2016 - what are the Parties real views on Green Energy ?



 Show me your friends and I'll show you your future - Anonymous

We can best tell what each Party's real views on green energy by looking at what groupings they join in the European Parliament. Last year the Commission presented it's energy union package outlining how it intends to achieve Europe's transition to a low carbon economy. 

Fine Gael are joined with the European People's Party (EPP), Sinn Fein are joined with European United Left/Nordic Green Left (GUE/NGL), and Labour are joined with Socialists and Democrats (S&D). Fianna Fail's current grouping is more problematic as discussed below.


The EPP, S&D and ALDE groups were more positive to the energy strategy, welcoming its enhanced focus on security and climate.

Fine Gael's grouping thought the energy union would lead to cheaper energy : 


The EPP found the proposals to be in line with the group's priority to assure "cheaper energy for citizens and enterprises". 

Labour's grouping wanted binding targets :

The S&D was pleased with the inclusion of a decarbonisation target but reiterated its call for binding targets to achieve the goals set by the strategy. 

Sinn Fein's Green leftist grouping surprisingly disapproved of the proposals :


GUE/NGL on the other hand disapproved of the proposals to involve the commission in energy agreements, unless it was requested by the member states concerned. 

 Sinn Fein's grouping are campaigning for 100% renewables by 2050, so it's uncertain as to why they disapproved of an energy union :

http://www.guengl.eu/policy/action/cop21-united-nations-conference-on-climate-change

Fianna Fail were joined with ALDE, a pro green energy group, but their remaining MEP last year defected to the European Conservatives and Reformists Group (ECR), the same grouping that has the British Tories and Ulster Unionist Party. The ECR seem to be pro-renewables but without the subsidies. They also support the extraction of shale gas. The Fianna Fail leader threatened to sack their MEP at the time he left the ALDE group but it appears as if he is still a Fianna Fail member.  So it's uncertain as to where Fianna Fail stand on the issue from a European perspective but they have recently issued a call for a full economic review into wind energy :

http://www.environ.ie/en/DevelopmentHousing/PlanningDevelopment/Planning/PublicConsultations/Submissions-WindEnergy/Unspecified/FileDownLoad,36278,en.pdf

Should they end up in power with Fine Gael and Labour, how much will they be forced to compromise on this promise ? Presumably it will end up on the sidelines like Alan Kelly's guidelines ?


RENUA, one of the newest political parties in Ireland are the only party to actually come out against wind energy : 


“Increasingly these main justifications[of wind energy] are falling apart,” it said. “Renua Ireland does not believe the economic case being made by supporters of wind farms and pylons, and throughout Europe wind farm energy is seen now as being a source of dear rather than cheap energy.

Again the compromise question arises here.

Lastly, there are no Irish MEPs aligned with the Europe of Freedom and Direct Democracy (EFDD) who are mostly against wind energy and the uneconomic renewable energies and includes UKIP. 

Most interestingly, it was Roger Helmer, an Englishman and member of UKIP, who asked a Parliamentary Question in the European Parliament on the EU and Ireland's lack of compliance with the Aarhus Convention :











Wednesday, 17 February 2016

2015 was Ireland's coldest year since 2010

Met Eireann have revealed that 2015 was not the hottest year on record for Ireland but actually the coldest since 2010 :

 A few other stations, mainly located in the Midlands and West, reported their lowest annual mean temperatures since 2010 - Met Eireann

As you can see, all stations bar one showed lower temperatures than the Long Term Average (LTA) :





Tuesday, 16 February 2016

Trinity engineer raising €10m for nuclear power technology

Interesting technology but as far as Im aware it was known about in the 1950s but not pursued at the time in America. At 150MW capacity, they would be fine replacements for our outdated peat power stations.


Article originally published in the Sunday Independent, written by John Reynolds


A Trinity College engineering graduate, who was named in this year's Forbes Europe Top 30 under-30 list, is raising €10m to develop a nuclear power technology that he and his partners claim could produce electricity more safely. It would also do so more cheaply than a new coal-fired power station or the latest nuclear one that Britain plans to build at a cost of up to €32bn, they say.


Founder of Energy Process Developments Rory O'Sullivan, 29, who has begun talking to a number of prospective Irish investors about the project, has partnered with British Moltex Energy founders environmentalist John Durham and scientist Dr Ian Scott, an entrepreneur and former chief scientist at consumer goods giant Unilever.
Cambridge-educated Dr Scott made a breakthrough in establishing that because of its design and how it works, by containing molten salt nuclear fuel in tubes, rather than hazardously pumping it around pipes, valves and heat exchangers outside a reactor, his stable salt reactor method, which keeps the fuel locked up in closed tubes, is far safer.
It also avoids the requirement for as much highly specialised, expensive and failsafe systems for cooling, containment and safety control, which raise new nuclear costs to levels that leave electricity billpayers and governments on the hook for tens of billions.
"We aim to win a slice of £250m funding the UK government has made available and have also established partners in Asia to develop the technology there. But we need further investment now to ensure we can take the lead internationally. Today's clean power technologies will not reduce global energy poverty at today's costs. Drastic cost reductions are required to implement clean power on a mammoth scale," O'Sullivan said.
Nuclear power is currently illegal here, but he added that the Moltex design could be used here in modular units that each generate about 150MW of power - enough for about 45,000 homes, potentially within the next 10 years.